home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- December 19, 1983SYRIABidding for a Bigger Role
-
-
- With cunning and ruthlessness, Syria seeks to become the prime
- Arab power
-
-
- In the heart of old Damascus sits the filigreed stone tomb of
- Saladin, the 12th century sultan who ruled an empire stretching
- from Cairo to Baghdad. Worshipers bound for the gleaming
- Umayyad mosque pass by without pausing, and children scamper in
- a nearby courtyard oblivious of his presence. Yet as the
- premier potentate of the region, the conqueror of Jerusalem and
- the fearless warrior who helped crush the Crusaders, Saladin
- united a divided region and set off a burst of pride among his
- people that glowed for centuries.
-
- Though aspirations and methods have been adjusted to the
- realities of the 1980s, the passion for hegemony lives on in
- Damascus. Under the shrewd, ruthless, brutally dictatorial
- guidance of President Hafez Assad, 53, Syria has been making a
- bid for the past decade to grasp the torch of Arab unity and
- emerge as the pre-eminent power in the Middle East. By keeping
- its 62,000 troops in Lebanon and by supporting factions opposed
- to the government of Lebanese President Amin Gemayel, Syria has
- become the key player in that fractured country's future. By
- fueling the raging rebellion within the Palestine Liberation
- Organization against Chairman Yasser Arafat, Syria is intent on
- seizing control of the Palestinian movement. Finally, by
- bullying and cajoling its Arab neighbors, Syria is building
- what it hopes will be a united front to reach its ultimate
- objective: a comprehensive, made-in-Damascus solution to the
- Arab-Israeli conflict.
-
- In pursuing those goals, Syria is pushing the battle-scarred
- region perilously close to yet another major war. Even if
- Syria does not risk confronting the U.S. as directly as it did
- in the skies over Lebanon last week, Assad has forced both the
- U.S. and the Soviet Union to become more deeply and more
- dangerously entwined in the Middle East muddle than perhaps
- either superpower would like. After its humiliating rout by
- Israeli force during their 1982 invasion of southern Lebanon,
- Syria has rebuilt its stock of military hardware to even greater
- levels with help from its chief sponsors, the Soviets.
-
- Though the Reagan administration initially sent U.S. Marines to
- Beirut last year to ensure the safe departure of Yasser
- Arafat's brigades from the Lebanese capital, Assad has helped
- keep U.S. forces mired there far longer than Washington
- anticipated. Faced with an Israeli-Lebanese accord that
- provided for the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Lebanon but
- failed to take account of Syria, Assad responded by stoutly
- refusing to pull out his own soldiers and by stirring the embers
- of hatred among the country's myriad factions against Israelis
- and Americans alike. The Reagan Administration, moreover, is
- convinced that Syria had prior knowledge of, and perhaps even
- masterminded, the October suicide-bombing of U.S. Marine
- headquarters in Beirut that killed 240 servicemen. For the past
- two months, Syrian antiaircraft batteries have taken potshots
- at U.S. reconnaissance planes over Syrian-controlled parts of
- Lebanon; when the barrage intensified two weeks ago, the U.S.
- responded with its Sunday-morning reprisal raid. With each
- passing week, Syria seems to grow bolder in striking out at the
- U.S. presence in Lebanon. Says a Syrian foreign ministry
- official: "Assad will do anything to convince the Americans
- that the road to peace must lead through Damascus, and this
- includes showing the Americans he can hurt them." With both
- U.S. and Soviet soldiers in the region, that strategy also risks
- igniting a super-power clash.
-
- At home, Assad has brought a stable government to a country
- that had rarely experienced that phenomenon before he came to
- power 13 years ago. His durability is especially noteworthy
- considering that Assad belongs to the Alawite sect, an offshoot
- of Shi'ite Islam that accounts for only 13% of his country's 9.6
- million people (most of the rest are Sunni Muslims). Assad's
- long tenure has, however, been purchased at great cost. The
- regime cruelly silences opponents both at home and abroad,
- maintains a standing army of 275,000, and has five intelligence
- agencies to keep watch on the citizenry.
-
- In recent weeks the state of Assad's health, always a crucial
- question in a one-man regime like Syria's, has become a subject
- of intense worldwide speculation. Syrian officials announced
- last month that their leader had suffered an attack of
- appendicitis. That diagnosis lost credibility when the patient
- failed to reappear for two weeks and word spread that he had
- had his appendix removed 20 years ago. Filmed news footage of
- Assad ostensibly sitting at a table with top officials and, a
- few days later, inspecting a bridge in Damascus, showed him to
- be wan and moving stiffly. Indeed, Arab diplomats began saying
- privately that the film had almost certainly been faked and that
- Assad remained seriously ill.
-
- Western diplomats in Damascus believe that Assad, who is
- diabetic, suffered a serious but not critical vascular
- incident, most likely a heart attack, and that he is slowly
- mending. According to Israeli intelligence sources, Assad has
- been instructed by doctors not to talk, so instead he spends
- his waking hours scribbling notes to aids. While both U.S. and
- Israeli officials believe that Assad is in full command of his
- senses, the consensus is that it will be some time before the
- Syrian President can resume his usual 18-hour workdays. There
- are conflicting rumors about who is running the country.
- Sources ranging from P.L.O. officials to Israeli Prime Minister
- Yitzhak Shamir have told reporters that a five-man council was
- making decisions, but hard facts are an elusive commodity in
- Damascus. Among the men reported to be on the committee are
- Rifaat Assad, Hafez's younger brother and the tough-hearted head
- of internal security, Foreign Minister Abdel Halim Khaddam and
- Defense Minister Mustafa Tlas. Even if Assad should die or
- become seriously incapacitated, sparking a ferocious power
- struggle, U.S. officials expect little change in Syrian policy
- once a successor emerges. "Damascus would be no less hostile
- to Israel and the U.S. and no less militarily dependent on the
- Soviet Union," says a U.S. analyst. "Syria is going to pursue
- the same pattern of behavior no matter who is in charge."
-
- The side of Syrian behavior that can perhaps be understood best
- is its activity in Lebanon. Syrians consider Lebanon to be
- part of "Greater Syria," a vague concept of territorial grandeur
- that thrives more in memory than in reality. Indeed, the two
- countries share more than a millennium of history. Both
- Lebanon and Syria achieved independence in the 1940s, but
- cultural and family ties still bind their populations, the
- Sunnis and the Druze. "We are one people," says a Syrian farmer
- living near the Lebanese border. "We go back and forth as if
- it were one nation." The ports of Beirut and Tripoli are
- Damascus' main links with the sea, while Syria serves as
- Lebanon's land route to Arab markets. For 28 years, until 1948,
- the two countries used the same currency, the Lebanese-Syrian
- pound. Tradition dictates that a new Lebanese President's first
- foreign trip is to Damascus (Amin Gemayel's maiden visit,
- scheduled for Nov. 13, was postponed because of Assad's
- illness). Says a Syrian official: "Lebanon is the one issue
- on which any Syrian President would be prepared to take the
- greatest risk."
-
- Indeed, Assad risked violent opposition at home and a cut in
- Arab aid when he invaded Lebanon in 1976. Syria's ostensible
- allies, the P.L.O. and a coalition of leftist Muslim forces,
- were about to crush the right-wing Christian militias when the
- Syrian army came to the rescue. Nearly five months later an
- Arab summit legitimized the Syrian presence under the rubric
- "Arab Deterrent Force," and Assad's soldiers have stayed ever
- since. Meantime, the Syrians have fought the Christians, whom
- they once saved from defeat, on several occasions. At some
- point or another, every Lebanese faction has sought Syria's
- help. Syria's prominent role in Lebanese politics is as much
- a result of Lebanon's invitations as of interference by
- Damascus. Currently the Druze, the Sunni leadership of Tripoli
- and anti-Phalangist Christians are allied with Syria through the
- National Salvation front, and Lebanon's mainstream Shi'ite
- organization, Amal, has its own ties to Damascus. Together
- these groups control all of Lebanon except Beirut, the
- Phalangist enclave north of the capital and certain patches of
- southern Lebanon where Israeli-sponsored militias operate.
-
- By refusing to pull out its forces, Syria in effect scrapped
- the Israeli-Lebanese accord of last May. That document, forged
- with the help of Secretary of State George Shultz, called for
- Israel to withdraw the 30,000 soldiers who remained in Lebanon
- after the previous summer's invasion. Though Assad was angered
- by being left out of the negotiations, he was even more livid
- that the treaty gave Jerusalem diplomatic and trade privileges
- with Lebanon. That collided with Assad's notion that Syria must
- not only retain influence in Lebanon, but ensure that Israel
- has none. Assad was virtually handed a veto over the treaty
- when Israel and the U.S. quickly signed a side letter saying
- the agreement would not be enforced unless Syria pulled its
- troops out as well. Says a senior west European diplomat in
- Damascus: "inept diplomacy by the U.S. and Israel made it easy
- for Assad to block what he least wanted. Lebanese concessions
- to Israel."
-
- Israel decided in September to pull its forces back a few miles
- to more defensible positions along the Awali River, a move that
- emboldened Syria. The strategic retreat, which took place
- before the Lebanese Army could fill the vacuum, allowed
- Syria-backed Druze and Palestinian forces to drive the Christian
- Phalangist militiamen out of the strategic Chouf Mountains. The
- fierce fighting produced a cease-fire agreement that favored
- the interests of Syria and its Lebanese proxies. The primary
- gain: Gemayel was forced to convene a reconciliation conference
- in Geneva to redistribute national power more fairly. Syria
- was granted an official role and dispatched to the talks.
-
- The meeting brought other accomplishments. The participants
- agreed to "freeze" the Israeli-Lebanese accord and identity."
- the next step comes when the Lebanese warlords are scheduled to
- reconvene in Geneva. Both Washington and Jerusalem want to
- retain the substance of the Lebanese-Israeli agreement; Assad
- considers it dead. If the pact is killed, according to a
- Western diplomat, Damascus is prepared to accept Gemayel as
- Lebanese president and work with him to restructure the
- country's government. Assad and Gemayel were scheduled to meet
- in Damascus in mid-November, but the Syrian leader's illness
- intervened. The Lebanese and Syrian foreign ministers, however,
- have met three times, most recently last week.
-
- Meanwhile Israeli troops continue to suffer casualties and
- antagonize local Shi'ites in southern Lebanon, and the U.S.
- Marines remain vulnerable in Beirut. Syria loses nothing by
- staying put. Says a Western diplomat in Damascus: "Assad
- knows that Israel is in a no-win situation that saps its
- military strength and that the Marines cannot stay in Lebanon
- forever. He is content to wait out both."
-
- Syria's relations with most other Arab countries range from
- mutual distrust to outright hatred. Saudi Arabia and the rest
- of the Persian Gulf oil states give Damascus more than $1
- billion a year in cash, partly because they deem it essential
- to have at least one strong Arab state confronting Israel. But
- the payment also serves as a form of protection money to ensure
- that Assad does not try to overthrow those conservative regimes.
- Kuwait, with its large population of Syrian guest workers,
- feels especially vulnerable. "Assad is a very bright man, but
- he also is very mean," says United Arab Emirates official. The
- Syrian leader and Jordan's King Hussein always have been deeply
- suspicious of each other. Assad grew furious last April when
- the monarch held talks with Arafat on President Reagan's 1982
- peace plan, which called for linking the Israeli-occupied West
- Bank and Gaza Strip in a loose association with Jordan. In
- October, when Arafat talked about renewing his discussions with
- Hussein, the Jordanian capital, Hussein read the terror campaign
- as a message from Damascus: Don't resume talks with Arafat --
- or else.
-
- Syria's ties with renegade non-Arab Iran, on the other hand,
- have been highly profitable for Damascus. When the Iran-Iraq
- war broke out in 1980, Assad, who has long been bitterly
- opposed to the Iraqi regime of Saddam Hussein, rushed to support
- the Ayatullah Ruhollah Khomeini. Aside from giving Damascus an
- estimated $600 million in cheap oil, the Ayatullah has bestowed
- his blessing on Assad's minority Alawites, a sect that most
- Sunnis consider heretical. In return, Damascus has shut down
- the Iraqi oil pipeline that slices across Syria to the
- Mediterranean, thereby slowing the flow of petrodollars to the
- financially strapped Baghdad government.
-
- According to Western and Israeli intelligence agencies, Syria
- gave at least tacit approval -- and possibly more -- to the
- Iranian terrorists who launched suicidal attacks against the
- American and French headquarters in Beirut and Israeli army
- offices in Tyre two months ago. Based in Baalbek, which is in
- Syrian-controlled eastern Lebanon, the Iranians acted under the
- auspices of Islamic Amal, a radical Shi'ite Muslim militia that
- broke away from the larger and more moderate Amal organization
- in early 1982. But they could not have undertaken the murderous
- task if Syria had disapproved. Says a Western diplomat: "The
- Syrians did not control and organize the operations, but certain
- elements in the Syrian regime knew what was going to happen and
- decided not to act."
-
- Syria's hand is more visible in the continuing campaign to
- destroy Arafat. Though Assad and the PLO chieftain have worked
- together in the past, the strains were always there. As early
- as 1969, when Assad was Defense Minister, he tried to regulate
- the activities of PLO guerrillas in Syria. As President, he
- supported Arafat's avowed enemy Abu Nidal, a rogue PLO leader
- who ran the Black June terrorist group. After the Lebanese
- civil war, Assad supported Beirut's right to impose rules on the
- PLO even though the group was far stronger than the government.
- While Assad saw the Palestinian cause as subordinate to his
- wider vision of Arab unity, Arafat believed the PLO must remain
- independent of any Arab nation. Differences in the personal
- styles of the two men also played a part in their estrangement. A
- lifelong military man, Assad is used to giving orders,
- expecting them to be obeyed and staying out of public sight,
- while Arafat, a thoroughly political animal, likes haggling,
- cutting deals and basking in the spotlight of publicity.
-
- Assad had long been looking for ways to clip Arafat, and the
- opportunity arrived last May: the PLO chief unwisely elevated
- several unpopular commanders within Fatah, the paramilitary
- group that he established and that still accounts for about 80%
- of the PLO's military strength. Palestinian fighters, outraged
- by Arafat's appointments and by his growing preference for
- negotiation over combat, rose up in revolt. Encouraged by
- Syria, and in some cases backed by Syrian troops and artillery,
- the rebels gained strength through the summer and eventually
- forced the loyalists out of Lebanon's Bekaa Valley and into
- Tripoli. When Arafat joined his forces into Tripoli. when
- Arafat joined his forces there in September, the time was ripe
- for Assad to finish him off.
-
- Instead, Syria blinked. As Arafat's forces retreated to
- Tripoli after putting up a fierce fight against superior numbers
- in the city's suburban refugee camps. it became clear that the
- wily chairman could hold out longer than expected. The Saudis
- and the Soviets, reluctant to see Arafat destroyed, began
- putting considerable pressure on Syria to accept a cease-fire.
- The pleas at first were ignored, but then Assad was
- hospitalized. Though it is impossible to say what role the
- President's illness played, Syria approved the alt in fighting.
- "His sickness prevented Assad from engaging in the extensive
- diplomacy necessary to resist the demands for a cease-fire,"
- speculates a Western ambassador in Damascus. "Perhaps the
- decision was made to take the easy way out."
-
- The siege seriously weakened the PLO and should permit Assad
- even more control over its affairs. The conflict, however,
- will switch from open warfare to internal wrangling if Arafat
- escapes from Tripoli and convenes a meeting of the PLO
- leadership. In that arena, the deftly persuasive Arafat usually
- triumphs. Though the rebel demands for "collective leadership"
- may limit his authority, Arafat may not lose as much power as
- Assad would desire. True, the revolt does make it nearly
- impossible for Arafat to win support for reopening talks with
- Jordan's Hussein on the Reagan peace plan, but the PLO leader
- was unable to get such backing before the rebellion anyway.
-
- Arafat's troubles are a good illustration of the complicated
- relationship between the Syrians and the Soviets. By
- midsummer, Moscow had let both Assad and Arafat know that it was
- highly displeased wit the rift. Aside from having nothing to
- gain from a fight between its two most valuable allies in the
- region, Moscow valued Arafat as an alternative to Assad for
- entry to the Arab world. Nonetheless, Syria pressed the fight
- until deciding on its own, for whatever reason, to hold back.
- Says a Damascus university professor: "The Soviets know that
- the Syrian decisions on Middle Eastern affairs, especially where
- Lebanon and the PLO are concerned, will always be independent."
-
- Created out of mutual need, the Soviet-Syrian marriage was
- consecrated in 1980, when Assad's growing sense of isolation in
- the Arab world and his burgeoning ambitions led him reluctantly
- to sign a treaty with the Soviet Union, which always has been
- eager to make friends in the Middle East. But for the next two
- years Assad failed to appoint an ambassador to Moscow. The
- devastating loss of an estimated $1 billion worth of military
- equipment by the Syrians during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon
- further dismayed the Soviets. After the war, however, Moscow
- upgraded the arsenal by some $2 billion. The Soviets supplied
- about 160 fighter aircraft, including advanced MiG-23s, to
- replace the 96 planes downed in dogfights over the Bekaa
- Valley. Some 800 T-72 tanks have been added to Syrian divisions,
- well above the number of older and smaller T-54s and T-55s lost
- in Lebanon. The Soviets have also shipped about 200 armored
- personnel carriers and between 600 and 800 trucks, considerably
- enhancing the mobility of Syrian troops.
-
- Moscow added a new element of instability to the region by
- installing the SA-5 missiles. With its range of 186 miles and
- electronic homing devices, the SA-5 is regarded as the most
- sophisticated surface-to-air missile in the Soviet inventory.
- Some 5,000 Soviet soldiers and technicians man the missile
- batteries and communications centers, while 3,000 Soviet
- advisers help train the Syrian army. Western military officials
- estimate that six to nine new SS-21 surface-to-surface missiles
- have been delivered and are being used for training. Though the
- Syrians already possess SCUD-B missiles, with nearly double the
- range of the SS-21s (167 miles vs. 75 miles), the new missiles
- are more accurate. In addition, the Syrians are boosting the
- number of missile launchers from 36 to 54. The recent
- deliveries are in line with Syria's policy of constantly
- improving its military capabilities, but they have led Syrian
- Defense Minister Mustafa Tlas to indulge in saber rattling.
- "The Negev is within the range of our missiles," he boasted in
- an interview with a Lebanese magazine. The Negev desert, about
- 200 miles from Damascus, is home is the Israeli nuclear reactor
- and several major airfields.
-
- Assad's wily relationship with Moscow is very much in character
- for a politician Richard Nixon once described as having
- "elements of genius." A onetime jet-fighter pilot, Assad is a
- cautious and pragmatic leader who nonetheless appreciates the
- uses - and limits -- of brinkmanship. Unfailingly courteous,
- the Syrian President inevitably begins meetings with a disarming
- jest before buckling down to what can become six hours of hard
- negotiating. "He gives his thoughts away bit by bit, like
- peeling an onion," says a Western diplomat. "He will just keep
- talking until you get tired." Assad has a superb grasp of
- detail and rarely refers to notes. On the other hand, he
- prefers to speak in generalities that sometimes are so ambiguous
- that diplomats leave his presence scratching their heads.
-
- His decision making can be equally mysterious. After listening
- expressionlessly to his small knot of Western-educated
- advisers, Assad usually retires to read voraciously about the
- question at hand, then flatly announces a decision, often by
- telephoning an aide late at night. Sometimes Assad holes up at
- his vacation home near the Mediterranean port of Latakia for
- several days and then returns with a series of directives.
- Neither a smoker nor a drinker, Assad, the father of five
- children, lives quietly with his wife Anisa in a heavily guarded
- villa in Damascus, 100 yards from his office. So enigmatic is
- Assad that his aides have dubbed him "the Sphinx."
-
- Even before he fell ill, the President was rarely seen in
- public. A joke is told in Damascus about he father and son who
- wait for days outside the presidential compound to catch a
- glimpse of Assad. Suddenly, a motorcade with sirens wailing
- roars down he street. As a Mercedes with blacked-out windows
- whizzes by, the beaming father turns to his son and says, "Now
- you can say you have seen the President."
-
- Born in an Alawite farming town near Latakia in 1930, Assad
- grew up keenly aware that he belonged to what was then the
- country's poorest and least-educated minority. The oldest son
- in a large family, Hafez credits his peasant father with
- instilling a strong nationalistic fervor in him, but at the same
- time reminding him to take pride in his Alawite heritage and the
- family name, which means "lion." Hafez plunged into political
- activism in high school, delivering fiery speeches against
- French rule. By about the time Syria gained full independence
- in 1946, Assad had joined the Baath party, which preaches a
- mixture of socialism and Arab nationalism.
-
- Few career paths were open to a non-Sunni in those days, so
- Assad's ambition led him to enter the air force college in
- 1952. His flying talent won him the best-aviator trophy upon
- graduation, but Assad's real interest remained politics.
- Disgruntled over Syria's union with Egypt in the late 1950s, an
- arrangement that he felt relegated Damascus to a secondary
- role, Assad and his colleagues founded a secret military group
- that helped the Baathists seize power in 1963. Assad became
- commander of the air force the next year and Minister of Defense
- in 1966. Though the Alawites ran the government, the 1967
- Arab-Israeli war was followed by a split within the party that
- pitted relative moderates like Assad against radical reformers
- seeking stronger ties with the Soviet Union. In 1970, Assad
- staged a bloodless coup and launched his "corrective movement."
- He lifted martial law, which had been in effect since 1967,
- halted the nationalization of industry and improved relations
- with Egypt and the conservative gulf states. Syria felt it had
- acquitted itself well in the 1973 war with Israel, vindicating
- its pitiful performance six years earlier. Diplomatic ties with
- the U.S., severed by the 1967 war, were resumed after Richard
- Nixon's visit to Damascus in 1974. Supplemented by handouts
- from the gulf states and revenues from its petroleum pipeline
- during the oil boom of the mid-1970s, Syria enjoyed its most
- prosperous years ever, with economic growth hitting an average
- rate of 13% in 1978.
-
- Then things started to sour. Syrian intervention in the
- Lebanese civil war proved immensely unpopular at home and
- triggered a wave of car bombs and assassination attempts against
- government officials, including three attacks on Foreign
- Minister Khaddam. Assad faced his most serious challenge from
- the Muslim Brotherhood, a radical Islamic group rabidly opposed
- to Damascus' secular policies. In June 1979 the group gunned
- down more than 60 cadets, mostly Alawites, at the Alepp military
- academy. The next spring, a general strike in northern Syria
- was stopped only after 12,000 troops killed hundreds and
- arrested thousands.
-
- If the Brotherhood's goal was to provoke more repression that
- in turn would alienate more Syrians from the regime, it
- succeeded. Since the late 1970s, the elaborate security
- apparatus -- which includes the Mokhabbarat, the secret police
- organization with some 20,000 to 30,000 members, and Saraya al
- Difa, a praetorian guard run by Assad's merciless brother Rifaat
- -- has grown more heavyhanded. After a bodyguard reportedly
- tried to kill Assad with a hand grenade in June 1980 (the
- President's life was saved when another guard threw himself on
- the explosive), some 250 to 300 political prisoners were
- massacred at Tadmur prison. In February 1982, when militants
- rebelled in Hama, the country's fifth-largest city, an edgy
- Assad responded by besieging the city of 200,000 for three weeks
- and killing at least 10,000 residents.
-
- Earlier this year, Amnesty International, the respected London-
- based group that monitors human rights violations around the
- world, released a 65-page report detailing abuses in Syria.
- The account makes chilling reading. Thousands have been jailed
- without charge, including former President Noureddine Atassi,
- who has been held in Damascus' Mezza military prison since his
- overthrow by Assad in 1970. Relatives of political suspects
- are sometimes held hostage until officials find their man; in
- one case, three family members were detained for nine years
- before their release in 1980. Twenty-three types of torture are
- listed in the report, including pouring boiling water on
- victims, electric shock and sexual abuse. An oft-used tactic
- is called dullab, in which a person is hung from a suspended
- tire and beaten with cables and whips. In one testimony, a
- 15-year-old boy told of being whipped and threatened with
- blindness if he did not reveal where his father was. Another
- student described a soundproof torture room in Aleppo that
- featured a machine called "the black slave." Recounted the
- youth: "When switched on, a very hot and sharp metal skewer
- enters the rear, burnings its way until it reaches the
- intestines, then returns only to be reinserted."
-
- The repression has increased the level of discontent, but not
- active opposition. Assad, moreover, has cultivated an almost
- fail-safe system against coups. Alawites occupy key posts in
- the party and the military. The armed forces are under
- separate command from the Mokhabbarat and the Saraya al Difa.
- Though Defense Minister Tlas is a Sunni, only Alawite officers
- are empowered to move strategically placed troops. Outfitted
- with the best equipment, Rifaat's 15,000-strong forces are
- stationed almost entirely around Damascus.
-
- A more serious threat to the regime may be the country's
- worsening economy. Plummeting oil revenues and bad harvests
- have drained foreign reserves. According to an International
- Monetary Fund report, Syria's total reserves (excluding gold)
- dropped from $927 million in mid-1981 to $40 million by early
- 1982. Electricity is now rationed nationwide. Though
- unemployment figures are not released by the government, more
- people are out of work than a year ago and inflation is on the
- rise. Syrians may not be going hungry, but foreign imports,
- including television sets and kitchen appliances, have been
- drastically cut. Consequently, the black market has exploded
- into the open, and corruption has become more rampant than ever.
- Even senior government officials openly smoke the Marlboros
- that can only be bought illegally.
-
- Assad's task of governing is complicated by the fact that while
- Damascus may be the oldest continuously inhabited city in the
- world, Syria is a relatively new country, where sectarian
- identities compete with national loyalties. The old and the
- new clash constantly; in the capital, women in black veils
- brush shoulders with secretaries wearing cheap knockoffs of
- West European fashions, while in the countryside the horse-drawn
- plow has yet to give way to the tractor. The contrast can
- sometimes be disconcerting. At graduation ceremonies for the
- "Revolutionary Youth" group, teen-age girls still demonstrate
- their newly acquired survival skills by biting live snakes
- behind the head to kill them and then cooking the reptiles over
- a campfire, to the delight of guests. Yet TV antennas bristle
- over biblical villages, and favorite programs include such U.S.
- fare as BJ and the Bear and Quincy.
-
- Assad's primary way of cementing Syrian loyalty remains the
- Arab cause, as it was Gamal Abdel Nasser's way in Egypt a
- quarter of a century ago. "The masses pride themselves on the
- fact that under Assad, Syria has been in the forefront of the
- struggle against Israel," says a Western observer in Damascus.
- One theory has it that the last thing Assad wants is a
- settlement with Israel; only by remaining at daggers' point with
- Jerusalem can the Syrian President justify the military machine
- that safeguards his government. Says an Arab editor in Beirut:
- "If peace suddenly broke out, the foundations of Assad's regime
- would be pulled out from under him." The prevailing view,
- however, is that Assad welcomes a solution, but only on his
- terms and at his pace.
-
- Says a Western foreign policy analyst in Damascus: "He is
- looking for an agreement that will assure his place in the Arab
- pantheon."
-
- In a sense, Assad has already achieved is primary goal: Syria
- is at the fulcrum of events in the region. Israeli
- intelligence officials argue that by stationing Marines in
- Lebanon, the U.S. played into Syrian hands, since Washington,
- in effect, put itself at the mercy of forces largely controlled
- by Assad. If the U.S. could leave the Lebanese quicksand
- tomorrow without losing face, and without the risk of causing
- further chaos by doing so, some Administration officials
- undoubtedly would grab the opportunity.
-
- Despite the escalation of tensions, Damascus has told
- Washington privately that it does not want to go to war over
- Lebanon. If a conflict were to break out, however, Syria could
- only gain; no matter how badly its forces fared against the U.S,
- standing up the American giant would strengthen Syria's
- credentials to be Arab standard-bearer. Though the terms of the
- 1980 Soviet pact with Damascus have never been revealed,
- officials in Moscow have hinted that Soviet troops would enter
- the fray only if Syrian territory were invaded. According to
- British intelligence officials, Moscow would unleash the
- Soviet-manned SA-5s to counter a full-scale Israeli move against
- Syrian-held Lebanon, but it would hold its fire in the face of
- a U.S. offensive, leaving it to the Syrians to retaliate.
-
- Administration officials believe that the Syrian attacks on
- U.S. reconnaissance planes were not an invitation to war but a
- probing of how much the U.S. would take. Observes Joyce Starr,
- a Middle East expert at Georgetown University's Center for
- Strategic and International Studies: "The Syrians are playing
- decibel politics. They heighten tensions for a few days, then
- lower them." Some Washington officials believe that Syria,
- after it stops testing U.S. resolve, will settle down and work
- out a deal with Gemayel six months to a year from now. In this
- view, once Gemayel shows progress -- no matter how scant -- in
- mending his country, the U.S. Marines will come home.
-
- Others contend that such an analysis is far too rosy. "Syria
- will never leave Lebanon unless it is forced to evacuate," says
- an Israeli general. Even if Syria is guaranteed influence in
- Lebanese affairs, according to British diplomats, Damascus will
- still insist on the return of the Israeli-occupied Golan
- Heights as the price for its withdrawal from Lebanon. Sooner
- or later, in the view of many Middle East experts in the U.S.
- and Western Europe, Syria must be brought into negotiations for
- a Palestinian homeland. As one senior British diplomat puts it:
- "Like it or not, Syria is the key to a Middle East settlement."
-
- Both Washington and Jerusalem seem reluctant to recognize that
- reality. Even if they did, Assad would probably prefer not to
- negotiate now. The Syrian President believes that the Arabs
- should deal with jerusalem only when they are as strong
- militarily as the Israelis, if not stronger. The Reagan
- Administration, moreover, has shown no interest in the kind of
- comprehensive talks, complete with Soviet representation, that
- Syria has demanded. Leaving aside the question of whether
- Moscow would be helpful or not, the White House is unwilling to
- grant the Kremlin any more influence in the region.
-
- In the meantime, the U.S.-Syrian relationship is likely to
- contain more jolts as American reconnaissance planes continue
- flying over Syrian antiaircraft batteries. America's long-term
- difficulties in dealing with Syria stem partly from the fact
- that, as one top U.S. diplomat put it, "our carrots and sticks
- are not great." By strengthening military ties with Israel two
- weeks ago, the Reagan Administration signaled that it was
- picking up the stick. Yet other Middle East experts point out
- that America achieved its greatest success with Syria by using
- carrots: Secretary of State Kissinger shuttled to Damascus
- more than 30 times to obtain a Syrian-Israeli disengagement
- agreement on the Golan Heights, a pact that is still in force.
- Says a staff member of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations
- Committee: "In the current round, we've refused to engage in
- that kind of stroking. We need to cater a bit to Assad's
- vanity."
-
- But the realities have changed since 1974, both for Assad at
- home and in the Middle East at large. No longer is Syria a
- third-rate military power. No longer is Egypt the unchallenged
- leader of the Arab world, a change that has opened a power
- vacuum for Damascus to fill. Now, and not then, Israeli
- soldiers face Syrian troops across a tense 37-mile front in
- Lebanon and 1,800 U.S. Marines are bunkered the Beirut. Assad's
- illness, no matter how quickly he recovers, just complicates an
- already impossible situation. "No war is possible without
- Egypt, and no peace is possible without Syria," Henry Kissinger
- once said It is a measure of how far Syria has come under Hafez
- Assad that while the first part of that statement is no longer
- completely valid, the last part rings truer than ever.
-
-
- By James Kelly. Reported by Barret Seaman/Washington and
- Roberto Suro/Damascus, with other bureaus.
-
- ____________________________________________________________
- Saladin's Shaky Successors
-
-
- To politicians and cartographers, Syria is an invention of the
- 20th century. To scholars, however, the term also refers to a
- once vast, occasionally powerful, always proud empire. Greater
- Syria, as historians call the broad area east of the
- Mediterranean, has a long and bloody past. That region, which
- included the territory of contemporary Syria, Lebanon, Jordan
- and Israel, was situated at the approximate point where Europe,
- Asia and Africa converge. As such, it was a traditional meeting
- place and killing ground for peoples of both the East and the
- West.
-
- Over the millenniums, Syria has repeatedly been overrun by
- conquerors from the desert or sea: Canaanites, Phoenicians,
- Hebrews, Arameans, Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks,
- Romans, Nabataeans, Byzantines, Arabs. During the 7th and 8th
- centuries A.D., Damascus flourished as the capital of the
- Umayyad Empire, which stretched from Spain to India. In the
- 12th century the Crusaders' brief reign came to a violent end
- at the hands of the warrior Saladin, who remains a Syrian folk
- hero to this day. After Saladin's death, his domain fell to
- stronger powers. Damascus was sacked and plundered in 1401 by
- Tamerlane, the Turkic conqueror, and in 1517 it came under the
- rule of the Ottoman Turks, where it languished for most of the
- next 400 years.
-
- That period ended at last in 1920, when Syria became an
- independent monarchy under King Faisal I of the Hashemite royal
- family. But Britain and France were at work redrawing the
- region's boundaries. Faisal's sovereignty ended after only a
- few months when the French claimed Syria under a League of
- Nations mandate. To weaken the Arab nationalist movement, the
- French created contemporary Lebanon by carving from Syria and
- Christian region around Mount Lebanon, the predominantly Muslim
- Bekaa Valley and the coastal cities of Tripoli, Beirut, Sidon
- and Tyre.
-
- Even as they never forgave the Crusaders who overran their
- homeland, the Syrians have never absolved the French for taking
- territory from them. After World War II, France reluctantly
- departed, and Syria became an independent republic. The
- Syrians still celebrate April 17, the date of the 1946 French
- withdrawal, as Evacuation Day.
-
- As with so many countries born in the past 40 years, Syria's
- modern history has been a saga of cops and countercoups. In
- 1958 Egypt's President Gamal Abdel Nasser merged his country
- with Syria to form the United Arab Republic, but the union
- lasted only 3.5 years. In 1963 the Arab Socialist Resurrection
- (or Baath) Party overthrew President Nazem Koudsi and seized
- power in Damascus.
-
- After leading a bloodless coup in 1970, Hafez Assad took over
- and appeared to be a relative moderate. He signed a
- disengagement agreement with Israel over the Golan Heights in
- 1974. He sent his army into Lebanon in 1976 to save the
- Maronite Christians from defeat by the Palestine Liberation
- Organization and a coalition of leftist Muslim forces. He told
- TIME Correspondent Wilton Wynn in 1977 that he was ready to make
- peace with the Israelis if they would withdraw from the
- territory they had captured in the 1967 war. But in the past
- three years, as he has fought against internal challenges,
- Assad's regime has become increasingly bloody and repressive.
- In the region, he has aligned himself with two menacing Islamic
- nationalists, Iran's Ayatullah Ruhollah Khomeini and Libya's
- Muammar Gaddafi. By the time President Reagan announced his
- peace initiative last year, Assad was fearful of Israeli gains
- in Lebanon and disenchanted with U.S. diplomacy. In no mood for
- negotiations, Assad believed that foreigners had trifled with
- Syria long enough.
-
- ____________________________________________________________
- His Brother's Keeper
-
-
- They help keep the peace by extorting protection money,
- threatening opponents with violence and even, it is said,
- robbing the plushest homes in Damascus for pocket money. Living
- in their own apartment buildings, publishing their own
- newspapers, they are a law - a world, really - unto themselves.
- Though their skintight dark green and strawberry-red camouflage
- uniforms have earned them the nickname "The Pink Panthers," they
- are certainly no pussycats. They are, says William Wuandt, a
- Middle East expert at the Brookings Institution, "very tough and
- widely disliked." In nearly every respect, the brutal,
- well-trained and ill-disciplined Defense Companies, Syria's most
- fearsome security network, reflect the characteristics of their
- leader: Rifaat Assad, 46, President Hafez Assad's younger
- brother and closest aide.
-
- With speculation rampant about the President's health and about
- who is running Syria during his illness, Rifaat has emerged as
- the central figure in the ten-member ruling inner circle. He
- is also widely considered to be the man most likely to try to
- succeed his brother. Ever since Hafez Assad first turned Syria
- into a one-man show after seizing power in 1970, Rifaat has not
- only served the regime with unflagging loyalty but has also had
- a hand in most of the nation's bloodier actions. "He is the
- one who keeps his brother in place," says one U.S. State
- Department official. In the midst of Syria's cutthroat
- factionalism, he may not be averse to taking that place himself.
-
- "Shrewd and dangerous as a snake," as a general in Israeli
- intelligence describes him, Rifaat flexes his muscles through
- the 280 tanks and 15,000 troops of the Defense Companies.
- Charged with the defense of metropolitan Damascus, Rifaat's men
- have sometimes been called on to defend the government from
- internal enemies. Last year, for example, they reportedly
- executed around 100 air force officers who had tried to stage
- a coup. In February 1982, some 8,000 of Rifaat's troops exacted
- a bloody revenge against the rebellious Muslim Brotherhood in
- the historic city of Hama, leaving most of the ancient quarter
- in ruins and at least 10,000 civilians dead.
-
- Rifaat's savagery at home has been complemented by his
- smoothness abroad. He has cultivated Crown Prince Abdullah of
- Saudi Arabia, whose government has given Syria an estimated $6
- billion over the past five years. He has worked to conciliate,
- and sometimes protect, PLO Leader Yasser Arafat. Last summer
- President Reagan publicly thanked him when, through contacts in
- the Iranian regime of Ayatullah Khomeini, Rifaat secured the
- release of David Dodge, acting president of the American
- University in Beirut, who had been kidnapped the previous year
- and abducted to Iran.
-
- Yet is Rifaat is the main guarantor of the regime's strength,
- he is also a major source of its frailty. He allegedly sits
- atop a nationwide ladder of corruption, an arrangement by which
- government officials on the take share payoffs with their
- immediate superiors. The bucks stop with Rifaat. Such shady
- enterprises as extorting money from drug traffickers in the
- Bekaa Valley and running guns throughout the Arab world have
- reportedly given him a personal fortune of around $100 million.
-
- While the President is an ascetic family man, Rifaat is an
- outright hedonist with seven wives, countless mistresses and 17
- children. After deciding to send two of his sons to college
- near Washington, D.C., Rifaat last year spent $1.1 million on
- a mansion in Potomac, Md., which he furnished with armed
- guards, housekeepers and other retainers. Just one month later,
- the house was severely damaged by a fire of unknown origin, and
- the entire entourage apparently fled the country.
-
- Despite their radically different habits, Rifaat and Hafez
- Assad share the same political goals. As members of the Alawite
- branch of Shi'ite Islam, both are determined to preserve the
- sect's control. The Alawites have dominated Syria for 13 years,
- mostly because of the adamantine grip of Hafez Assad. "In the
- short term," says a Western diplomat, "there is no hope for a
- non-Alawite breakthrough." Yet were his older brother no
- longer in control, Rifaat might find it politic to install as
- a figurehead President a Sunni from the country's inner circle,
- someone whose name is less sullied than his own. A likely
- beneficiary of such a ploy might be Major General Mustafa Tlas,
- the Defense Minister and a harsh critic of the U.S., who has
- been hailed by Soviet Defense Minister Dimitri Ustinov as "the
- greatest strategist in the Middle East." Another Sunni front
- runner is Chief of Staff Hikmmat Shehabi, an ambitious, somewhat
- colorless soldier who was made Syria's official contact with the
- U.S. diplomatic mission in Damascus ten years ago. During a
- transition period, a third Sunni might also prove influential:
- the abrasive, crisply competent Abdel Halim Khaddam, Foreign
- Minister for more than ten years.
-
- No matter who emerges as a potential successor to Hafez Assad,
- the regime's reputation for ruthlessness is likely to remain
- intact. Says Amiram Nir, a scholar at Tel Aviv University's
- Center for Strategic Studies: "The hands of all the caste
- members [the inner circle] are dirty. They all share personal
- involvement in "counterrevolutionary" bloodbaths." The road to
- power is therefore sure to be treacherous. Almost three years
- ago, when Major General Naji Jamil, commander of the air force,
- managed to ingratiate himself with Hafez Assad, Rifaat
- interceded forcefully. Jamil was stripped of his power and
- confined to his house, where he is kept under surveillance to
- this day.
-
-
-